In 1854, the first Church of England service in Euroa was held at the Seven Creeks Hotel by Rev. Singleton. Mr. J. De Boos conducted services at his home, and a Sunday school was established in a bark hut. Various clergy traveled from Melbourne to conduct services, notably on their way to the goldfields at Beechworth.

Before a church was built, a school building with a dirt floor was constructed on the C of E reserve. This later became part of the current Rectory. The church building was completed in 1884 at a cost of £800, and opened in 1885 with Rev. F.L. Wilson as the first resident priest.

Over the years, extensions were made to the Rectory and a hall was constructed. Tragedy struck with the deaths of Rev. Wiltshire and Rev. Charles Christopher Godden. Rev. Gordon Nelson oversaw the completion of the Rectory during his tenure.

In 1929, an extension to the Church was started, including a bell tower above the Chancel. Despite financial challenges during the Great Depression, the building was completed.

St. Paul’s had an active choir and Sunday school for many years, with clergy including Canon Scott, Rev. Selwyn Ide, Rev. Claude Kennedy, and Rev. Albert Strickland.